top of page
Website Benner Opening.jpg

Get excited

OPENING APRIL 16

Today's Offerings

YOUR TABLE. OUR FOOD.

A great selection of freshly prepared foods - always ready to go!

EVERYDAY MENU

These customer favorites are ALWAYS AVAILABLE!!

DAILY SPECIALS

Follow us on social media for daily updates.

Salads

Black Sheep Chicken Salad

Black Sheep Tuna Salad

Black Sheep Egg Salad

Power Up Salad

Quinoa Salad

Corn Tomato Arugula

Tomato Cucumber Salad

Tomato Mozzarella

Sesame Rice Noodles

Classic Cole Slaw

Potato Salad

Pasta Peas & Parm

Chickpea Salad

Mediterranean Cous Cous

 

Entrees

Roasted Semi Boneless 1/2 BBQ Chicken

Marinated Grilled Hangar Steak

Pan Seared Salmon

Grilled Lemon Honey Shrimp

Panko Crusted Chicken Tenders

Simple Grilled Chicken

Grab & Go Sandwiches on Ciabatta Roll

House Roast Beef w/ Arugula, Tomato, Brie and Béarnaise Aioli

Country Ham w/ Greens, Tomato, Swiss & Roasted Onion Spread

Roasted Turkey w/ Greens, Tomato, Provolone, Basil Aioli

Caprese Sandwich w/ Nut Free Pesto Spread

Prosciutto Caprese w/ Nut Free Pesto Spread

 

Grab & Go Salads

Seasonal Garden Salad w/ House Vinaigrette

Greek Salad w/ Red Wine Vinaigrette

Kale Caesar Salad w/ House Croutons

Breakfast Sandwiches - Served Till 11AM

Classic - Egg, Cheddar and Applewood Smoked Bacon

Black Sheep - Egg, Prosciutto, Tomato, Onion, Arugula and Herb Spread

Piggy - Egg, Cheddar, House Maple Sage Sausage, Arugula, Hollandaise Aioli

Smokey - Everything Seed Bagel w / Smoked Salmon, Capers, Red      Onion, Tomato, Cucumbers and Arugula

Choose English Muffin, Brioche, Croissant or Breadless

Smoky Ham also available

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Instagram

Follow us to get a daily update

of special offerings!

CATERING. YOUR WAY.

don't be disappointed...

we hate to say no, but due to popularity, sometimes we reach capacity

ORDER EARLY TO GUARANTEE YOUR DATE

CARRY-OUT CATERING

3 days (72 hrs) advance notice MINIMUM

 

You can order almost anything from our Catering Menus and pick it up during normal business hours. (A few special items require longer order and preparation time). All orders subject to availability.

CUSTOM CATERING

7 days advance notice MINIMUM

 

Let our menus serve as a starting point. We can work together and tailor a custom feast for your special event.  We can also provide on-site staffing to set up and serve (depending on availability). 

MENUS

All subject to availability.

Appetizer

Summer Celebrations

Subject to availability

Home Entertaining

Subject to availability

Brunch

Subject to availability

Weddings

Subject to availability

Catering
Our Promise
Mark_Behind Counter.jpg

OUR PROMISE

In these unusual times, we remain as dedicated as ever to providing you with the highest quality food products and exceptional customer service. We are undertaking many additional precautions, following all orders of the State, and working hard to safely get our food on your tables.

We look forward to serving you.

mark signature.png

Mark Venette

Owner & Enthusiastic Sheep Herder

L1020042.jpg

FIND US

Black Sheep
17 Airport Road
Edgartown, MA 02539
508-338-7770

Find Us
bottom of page